Amnon Marinov was a figure of both profound intellect and significant controversy within the world of nuclear physics. A long-time professor at the Hebrew University of Jerusalem, Marinov dedicated his life to pushing the boundaries of the periodic table, specifically searching for "superheavy elements" (SHE) and the theoretical "Island of Stability." His career is a testament to the rigorous, often lonely pursuit of scientific discovery that challenges established paradigms.
1. Biography: Early Life and Academic Trajectory
Amnon Marinov was born in Jerusalem in 1930, during the British Mandate for Palestine. He grew up in a period of intense geopolitical transformation, which perhaps contributed to his resilient and independent character.
Education
He pursued his higher education at the Hebrew University of Jerusalem, receiving his Ph.D. in 1962. His early research focused on nuclear reactions and the structure of the atomic nucleus.
Career Path
Following his doctoral studies, Marinov spent several years in the United States as a research associate at the Argonne National Laboratory (1963–1965), a premier center for nuclear research.
Academic Position
Upon returning to Israel, he joined the faculty of the Racah Institute of Physics at the Hebrew University. He rose through the ranks to become a Full Professor, a position he held until his retirement, though he remained an active "Professor Emeritus" until his death in 2011.
2. Major Contributions: The Search for Superheavy Elements
Marinov’s primary contribution to physics was his relentless investigation into elements beyond the known periodic table.
-
The 1971 "Element 112" Experiment
In 1971, Marinov and his team at the Rutherford High Energy Laboratory in the UK published a bombshell paper. They claimed to have discovered element 112 (later named Copernicium) by bombarding tungsten targets with high-energy protons. This was revolutionary because it suggested superheavy elements could be produced through "secondary reactions" rather than direct heavy-ion bombardment.
-
The Search for Elements in Nature
Unlike many of his peers who looked for superheavy elements exclusively in particle accelerators, Marinov spent decades searching for them in nature. He hypothesized that if certain superheavy isotopes were stable enough (the "Island of Stability"), they might exist in trace amounts in minerals like gold or thorium.
-
Discovery of Long-Lived Isomeric States
Marinov contributed significantly to the understanding of "isomers"—nuclei in excited states that last much longer than usual. He argued that these states could explain why some superheavy elements might survive for millions of years.
3. Notable Publications
Marinov’s bibliography is characterized by several high-impact (and high-debate) papers:
- Evidence for the Possible Existence of a Superheavy Element with Atomic Number 112 (Nature, 1971): This paper brought him international fame. While the scientific community later concluded the evidence was insufficient, it sparked a global race to find element 112.
- Evidence for a long-lived isomer of 236Rg (Z = 111) in natural Au (International Journal of Modern Physics E, 2009): In his later years, Marinov published findings claiming to have found Roentgenium in natural gold samples using Inductively Coupled Plasma Mass Spectrometry (ICP-MS).
- Evidence for a long-lived superheavy nucleus with atomic mass number A=292 and atomic number Z ≥ 122 in natural Th (arXiv, 2008): Perhaps his most controversial work, where he claimed to have discovered Unbibium (element 122) in a purified solution of thorium.
4. Awards and Recognition
While Marinov did not receive the Nobel Prize or the Wolf Prize—largely due to the non-reproducibility of his most famous claims—he was highly regarded within the Israeli physical society.
- Fellowships: He was a member of the American Physical Society and the Israel Physical Society.
- Institutional Legacy: He was a cornerstone of the Racah Institute, mentoring generations of Israeli nuclear physicists and securing the Hebrew University’s reputation as a hub for high-energy nuclear research.
5. Impact and Legacy: The "Marinov Controversy"
Marinov’s legacy is complex. In the scientific community, "discovery" requires independent verification. Because other major labs (such as GSI in Germany or Dubna in Russia) could not replicate his 1971 or 2008 results, official credit for element 112 was eventually given to Sigurd Hofmann’s team at GSI.
However, Marinov’s impact remains significant for two reasons:
- Methodological Rigor: He pioneered the use of mass spectrometry to search for superheavy elements in natural ores, a technique that refined how physicists look for rare isotopes.
- Intellectual Persistence: He forced the scientific establishment to constantly re-evaluate the "Island of Stability." Even his critics acknowledged his deep understanding of nuclear physics and his ability to find anomalies in data that others overlooked.
6. Collaborations
Marinov was a highly collaborative researcher, often working across international borders:
- Reinhard Brandt: A long-time collaborator from the Philipps-Universität Marburg, Germany. Together, they spent decades investigating "anomalous" nuclear phenomena.
- The Rutherford Laboratory Team: His 1971 work involved a large team of British and Israeli scientists, illustrating his ability to lead multi-national experimental efforts.
- Students: He mentored numerous Ph.D. students at Hebrew University who went on to lead departments in Israel and the US, ensuring his pedagogical influence outlived his specific theories.
7. Lesser-Known Facts
- The "Lone Wolf" of Physics: In his later years, Marinov was often viewed as a "maverick." When major journals refused to publish his claim about element 122, he took the then-unconventional step of uploading his research to arXiv.org, sparking a massive online debate among physicists worldwide.
- A Jerusalem Man: Despite his international career, Marinov was deeply rooted in Jerusalem. He was known for his modesty and his habit of working late into the night at the Racah Institute, often seen walking the halls of the Givat Ram campus long after his colleagues had gone home.
- The Thorium Mystery: To this day, the "Marinov peaks" in his mass spectrometry data of thorium remain a point of curiosity. While most attribute them to molecular artifacts, a small minority of researchers still wonder if Marinov had indeed stumbled upon a new class of long-lived nuclear states.
Amnon Marinov passed away in 2011 at the age of 81. He remains a symbol of the "heroic age" of nuclear physics—a scientist who was unafraid to stand by his data, even when it placed him at odds with the rest of the world.